Friday, May 8, 2009

This week has been...

- getting stopped (twice!) by the armed guard (by armed I mean AK 47 armed and by guard I mean young man in street clothes, which sometimes means a purple sequined shirt, or something else equally in line with men’s fashion here) because he thought I was a local and therefore needed to show my student ID (foreigners don’t need to show anything)

- not getting lost, neither on the way there or the way back, for the first time, going to my tutor’s house Wednesday

- a new yoga class—same place, new teacher (this time an Indian woman), new price (about $12 per class) and a lot more people. So much for my $5 private lessons…although the legitimacy level of the class certainly corresponds with the price

- and my walks to yoga, now in the evenings, past the overflowing gardens of every apartment block, branches of blossoming trees reaching into the sidewalk, whose scents gladly overpower the diesel fumes from the busy road on which I walk. Women walking stop and sniff their neighbor’s bushes, break off a twig to bring home or give to a friend, old women puttering around their rose gardens, endlessly washing and cleaning and trimming. It is spring! and the weather is in the seventies and eighties every day and forties and fifties in the evening

- spring also means spring cleaning; every house with their winter rugs out to dry, then rolled up and stored away til next year

- it also means buying boxes and boxes and kilos and kilos of fool (beans), which is now in its agricultural prime, to cook and freeze for the year, and kilos and kilos and kilos of bazila (peas), for the same reason, and hours and hours and hours of shelling them (my host mother had been doing it all day Tuesday, then at night they invited our Finnish neighbors over for knafe dessert and everyone helped out, then they left and the shelling continued til 1 am)

- walking back from yoga to night games in the soccer stadium across the street from my house: taxis pulled over on the side of the road, their drivers clinging to the fences trying to get a glimpse of the game, two men watching from a broken bed frame abandoned on the side of the road, huddled under a blanket, and the stadium lights glaring directly into my bedroom

- a midterm this past Sunday, which means the class is now more than half-over

- reading Syrian authors in our new unit on short stories and poetry

- and a holiday on Wednesday for the Shohodah (martyrs executed in Beirut and Damascus in 1916 by Ottomans); celebrated by my family with everyone off from work and school and a lunch in the garden of grilled kibbe patties and tabbouleh.

- Also, it’s May! How and When did that happen? Six more weeks…

Weekend Update, pt. 2

This past weekend I went north to Krak des Chevaliers for a second visit, although this time under slightly different circumstances. I went up with a group called the Hash House Harriers, an international running group that has branches in most major cities around the world (here it seems to be predominantly based around the embassy community). I first heard about them when I was visiting Rachel in Amman and we were discussing the frustrations of not being able to run outside (due to pollution, city drivers and city streets, getting weird looks). She told me about HHH and said that they had a chapter in Damascus that I should look up when I get back.

A few weeks later when I was back in school, I was talking about the same thing with my friend Sam from class and it turned out that his friend had joined the group and that he was going on his first run that coming weekend. He called me on his way back from the run and told me how they had gone for a run outside of the city into the mountains and had gotten really lost and that it was great and I should join them next time.

Apparently I picked a really good time to join the group; this weekend was a shared trip between the Beiruti and Damascene branches in celebration of Damascus’s 1500th run (also called hashes; also divide 1500 by 52 weeks to figure out how many years they’ve been running in Damascus). The trip cost $90 and included transportation to and from, hotel for one night, four meals, entrance to the castle and most importantly, in the eyes of the participants, lots and lots and lots of beer. The group’s motto is “drinkers with a running problem” and they manage to live up to it quite well; they also shared an obscene sense of humor and a few of them also happened to be serious runners with backgrounds in ultra running, marathons, half-marathons, triathalons. I should also mention that Sam, myself, and Sam’s friend Alex were the only participants under the age of 30 (also the only Americans), and the vast majority was probably over 50. Most of them worked together at various embassies, the European Commission, or some UN group. There was a large constituency from Northern Europe (Fins, Danes, Norwegians), one from Ireland, 1 Dutch, 2 Canadians, 1 South African, 2 Egyptians, and the rest were from Syria and Lebanon.

But before I could go running, I realized that I had to get myself a pair of running shoes. I had left my sneakers at home in CT, figuring I would more likely go hiking than run in the city, so I would have to buy a new pair if I wanted to go on the trip. Finding real running shoes here turned out to be an adventure in itself. My older host brother, Ihab, had suggested that I look in the Adidas and Diadora shops in Qassa, a neighborhood near our house, on the way to the Old City, and of course I put off the task until the day before the trip.

On my way there, I looked in vain for a local shop that might sell the same merchandise—1) because I had no idea how much imported running sneakers would cost and 2) I realized that if I didn’t find them in these shops I had no idea where else to look. There are a few ‘sporty’ shops, but most of them sell sports fashion and casual ‘sporty’ shoes without the actual function of using them for sportly activities. Even asking for running sneakers in these stores was difficult because if I specified ‘women’s’ shoes they would point me in the direction of the casual fashionable type and also most salespeople didn’t know the difference between an actual running shoe and any other sneaker.

I figured I would have better luck in Adidas. I did, at first, but it was a small shop, and it only had a few models for running sneakers, though my options were expanded slightly when I told them my shoe size and I realized I might have better luck looking in the men’s section. But they didn’t have my size anyway, so I went on to Diadora, where I had the same problem (plus the sneakers were all ugly). I had run out of options, so I called my Syrian friend Ibrahim, hoping he would have a better idea of what to do. After we worked out what I was looking for “sneakers” not “snickers” and so on, he told me he would check with a few friends because he had no idea and didn’t want me to pay full price at expensive shops so he would call me back.

An hour later he called me to say that I could go to a store south of the city where they sold smuggled goods from Turkey. He told me he would try and come with me if he could (he wanted to look for Harley Davidson shirts), but if I wanted to go alone he could explain the directions. Take a bus to Someria garage (about 30 minutes from my house), then get on this bus to this place, then get out here and ask how to get here… I told him that if he couldn’t make it, I would look elsewhere because I didn’t want to go alone to the shop in the first place, and secondly it didn’t sound like I would ever make it there anyway. He called me back an hour later and said he was too busy to go that afternoon.

I returned to my house and found Ihab there, so I asked him again for ideas of where to buy sneakers. This time he recommended going to the malls on the outskirts of the city (I didn’t even know that we had malls!) where there were Nike, Puma and Adidas stores. I was about to leave the house (by now it was after 7 pm) when another one of my Syrian friends that I had called earlier called me back and also recommended the malls, but then she offered to drive me there. Hoooorray for people with cars!

About an hour later I had met up with her and we headed for the malls, stopping first to pick up her 2 ½ year old nephew to bring with us. He had curly blond hair and blue eyes and was dressed more fashionably than I was, with his black and white checkered Van slip-on shoes, skinny jeans and Hurley hoodie.

The first mall we went to was Cham City Center, a pretty normal looking mall, though smaller than the ones in Beirut. We checked out the Adidas store first, but again they didn’t have my size, so we left the mall for the one directly next door, which had just opened and was in a building originally intended for a medical center, making it the strangest mall I had ever been in. It had a pretty large Nike store, though it sold more clothes than shoes, and only offered about three models of women’s running sneakers, and of course none of them fit me. There were two men’s options that fit, though one was $150 because it had a chip inside that counted your mileage for you (though they didn’t have the computer attachment to read the chip in stock), and the other one was decent but still pretty ugly. So we went to Puma, found nothing, and finally returned to Nike to buy my sneakers, relieved that the whole process was finally over and I wouldn’t have to back out of the trip after all.

Before we left we visited the supermarket in the first mall, mostly because I hadn’t been to one here yet, but also because my friend works for the marketing department of a food distribution company and has to go check up on their products and how they are being displayed etc etc. She pointed out to me the difference between smuggled goods and legally traded goods (smuggled goods don’t have any Arabic writing on them) and I was surprised to see that somewhere like one of the largest/only supermarkets in the city would sell smuggled foods. Looking down the aisles and aisles of familiar brands just made me grateful that I didn’t have to do my own food shopping here, and could resist the temptation of eating my favorite cereals with skim milk for breakfast every morning but having to come all the way out to the malls to find it (everything will taste all the better when I finally go home again).

--

The next morning, after a late night out and an early rise, we met up around 10 am and set off on our 3-4 hour ride north, arrived for a quick lunch at the hotel, then changed and met to get back on the bus and drive to the castle, where we would start our run, ending back at the hotel. I had to cringe a little on the inside and hold my tongue against better LNT judgement when, in our circle before the run, the organizers of the run (the mis-management) announced that we could follow their trail according to piles of shredded office paper in celebration of a weekend away from paperwork. The leader of the Damascus group, an older Danish guy named Viggo, read aloud from Wikipedia about important events of the year 1500 (to celebrate the 1500th run) and the day May 1st in history.

The area around the citadel is, in a word, hilly, and if you remember from our photos from our trip last month, also really really beautiful (unfortunately I didn’t run with my camera, but Gustav, the resident marathon/ultra runner, did—he would often stop to take the perfect shot of the group, the landscape or a flower, and then sprint ahead to the front of the group—hopefully we will get some of his photos soon). We split into two groups of walkers and runners and began the run on the road next to the citadel but soon moved off-road to a newly-forged trail in the fields of unfortunately thorny wildflowers. Our paper trail got us lost pretty frequently (for one because sometimes they blew away, for another because the trails are designed to confuse you and take you down false paths) and once we got off the smooth pavement onto the uneven and rocky trails and had to bushwack through long grasses with lotso thorns, we ended up walking most of the time, following shouts of “On On!” from the head runner when s/he discovered new trail markings.

By the end of the run we had completely lost the trail and just cut across the hillside directly to the hotel. Unfortunately the weather was not nice enough to enjoy the unheated hotel pool (although two or three still opted to jump in) and most people waited for the walkers to catch up sitting in chair with a beer in hand (I stuck to my water bottle). Once everyone had gathered again, the group circled up to partake in one of the HHHs most important traditions: inducting new members, christening relatively new members with nicknames, and calling out old members for transgressions against the group (ie. wearing matching clothes, smoking on the run, wearing new shoes [somehow I was exempt from the fate of having to drink out of my newly broken-in sneakers [drink beer filtered through my dirty socks, that is]]…). There was plenty of ceremony and ritual involved, most of which is best left undescribed, but suffice it to say that it kept the people eating lunch in the restaurant above the pool area well-entertained (as were the poor hotel guests that had to share the restaurant with us for dinner later that night).

The next day we circled up again after breakfast for run #1501, again with an introduction of Wikipedia facts. This time the run was predominantly downhill along the road and fairly easy to follow and it ended by following a driveway up a hill through a someone’s backyard and vegetable garden (“Don’t step on the fool!”) up to St. George’s Monastery. We were certainly a strange sight in front of this church, hanging out in spandex and running shorts, most people drinking beer and smoking. A group of us went inside the church, though a few were turned away by the priest for indecent dress, and found ourselves walking into a prayer service. The women had veiled their hair and after singing they filed to the front, which was covered in icons, and knelt, praying in front of the icons. When they stood up again I was surprised to see the faces of the icons were blacked out from being rubbed.

That day was much nicer than the day before, and while we waited for the walkers to catch up everyone was dreaming of the hotel pool. However, once they returned we realized one of the walkers was missing, so we waited a bit longer and a bit longer (Gustav decided to run back to the hotel), and then finally got back on the bus to go to the hotel and look for him. The lost walker was there, already showered and changed, and Gustav had already been for a swim in the pool that was somehow colder than the day before.

After the post-run circle, we all changed and checked out of the hotel and headed to lunch at a restaurant on the way to visit the castle. Our visit started off with a bit of chaos as we tried to figure out how many Syrians, foreigners living in Syria, Lebanese, and foreigners living in Lebanon we were, since they all paid different entrance fees, and then we gathered up for a brief historical introduction to the citadel from our resident PhD in Archaeology, then split up to explore the citadel to our liking, trying not to get too lost and get back to the bus again in one group. From there, the Lebanese group headed back to Beirut and the rest of us to Damascus and so ended my first hashing experience. I came home to studying for my midterm the next day and early sleep.

Thursday, April 30, 2009

Yuthir-ing Al-Jadl

This past week of class has been typified mostly by the Arabic phrase “yuthir al-jadl” (to stir up debate). When it was first introduced in a vocabulary lesson, one of the students gave the example, “The differences between Syrians and Lebanese stirs up debate.” Immediately our professor jumped in and argued that there are no differences between the Syrians and Lebanese and thus there is no debate. We then spent the next 15 minutes arguing about if there are differences, what they are, and whether or not Syria entered Lebanon lawfully and orderly in order to protect their neighbor (and their own former citizens) in distress. Henceforth the issue, did indeeed, stir up debate.

In the same way, it seems that there is no issue we can talk about in class, no matter how benign, that doesn’t lead to some animated discussion about Israel/Palestine, Middle East v. West, or the Media. One morning there were only three of us in class, so we spent the first hour talking about the news. I mentioned that I had had a conversation with my private tutor (p.s., I have a private tutor now, more on that later) about how Western news channels will all broadcast the same inane news items about the president or other celebrities/public figures (the example at hand was a bird that was loose in the White House, or from the past, the death of Pres. Bush’s cat), whereas from an Arab perspective (such as that of my tutor’s) it was incredibly stupid and meaningless. I tried to explain that Americans like to feel like the people that they put on a political or social pedestal are sometimes just like the rest of us and that they can relate to them as individuals. My professor in class then turned that discussion into how CNN/BBC may broadcast news about birds in the White House but not footage from the Israeli invasion of Gaza this past winter. Or on the other hand, how Arab stations may not have personal information about their heads of state but they did enter directly into the place of conflict and many correspondents lost their lives capturing the events that took place. So which one is free media?

Or another favorite topic: Racism! Our reading for this unit was about Arab immigrants in European countries and the prejudices they endure, particularly in the job market and particularly when Arab = Muslim = Terrorist in the minds of the local people. Our conversation then turned to our professor’s experiences in Italy and the kind of disrespect that she encountered for wearing a hijab, and the kind of disrespect she has encountered working in language institute from (the few) foreign students who have no interest in the local culture, but only want to learn the language for work reasons, and throughout their stay maintain significant prejudices against Arab culture and Muslims in particular. I was surprised to know that someone would actually choose to live here and study in a local institute in a country that is 90% Muslim and the whole time be walking around with hatred and prejudice for just about every person s/he met. What a torturous way to spend six months.

So although these lessons have been somewhat enlightening, or at the very least, entertaining, it has already gotten a little old and a bit frustrating when you can’t even get through a single lesson without stumbling onto some controversial tangent that you didn’t even know you were bringing up. While its good to learn how to defend yourself in a heated argument, the problem ultimately lies in the fact that our professor always has the upperhand of language, and we are always limited by our ability to articulate our own ideas and are always forced to make blatant generalizations that we would never make in English. Last example: today in class, one student was giving a presentation on the Barbary pirates and he referred to part of Northern Africa as the Barbary States (doul barbary) and our professor immediately called him out on being prejudiced. She thought he was referring to them as Barbarian states, i.e. without a legitimate culture or civilization (and the word ‘barbarian’ is derived from the Berbers). However the problem lay in the translation from English to Arabic and not in his prejudicism, because in English there is a difference between Barbary and Barbarian, but in Arabic apparently they refer to the same thing. Another student pointed out that it is the same problem with the name “Sudan,” which comes from the Arabic word for black and literally means “country of the blacks.” Eventually we moved on but the presenter dug himself into another hole when he said that the pirates found religious justification for their actions in the Q’ran and our prof. demanded to know where it was written that it is justified to kidnap and ransack your non-Muslim neighbors on the basis of religion (and thus you see the same problem with terrorists today, it lies in the varied interpretations of the text).

--

So. I have a tutor now! I found her through a friend from Georgetown who was in Damascus last year and who worked with her studying Arab Media. Since I’m supposed to be doing the same thing for the class that I am missing at Georgetown, I figured that the best way to keep up would also be with a tutor and some sort of structured lessons involving practicing discussion (since I don’t get enough of it in class). My friend warned me that she wasn’t great at grammar (which I have now learned for myself once we had something of a standoff over a simple grammar exercise in my first lesson). So now twice a week in the afternoons I’ll be making my way out to the suburbs of Damascus to meet with Leila at her house.

The first time I went, I thought it would be easier to take a taxi directly there, rather than deal with the service (minibus) and having to figure out when to get out. But unfortunately my taxi managed to get into a (minor) car accident and had to pull over to sort it out with the other driver, so I gave up and decided to take a service anyway (it only costs 7 lira compared to the usual 10 and it’s the first time I’ve ever seen a 1 lira coin). I told the driver the name of the stop and that I didn’t know where I was going, so he told me where to get off and Leila’s son came out to meet me and show me the way to her house.

The next time that I went, aka yesterday, I thought I had perhaps seen enough of the way to her house to figure it out on my own, so I tried to keep a lookout and figure out when to get out. However the first time the drive seemed much longer, so I was completely disoriented and it was only when we crossed a highway and I saw the driver giving me funny looks that I looked up and realized that we were already on our way back to Abbasiyin Square, where I live. He let me down and I took a taxi. But even then I couldn’t find the house and I walked in and out of little alleyways trying to recognize something, until I finally called her and realized that I was looking on the wrong side of the street. Her son came out again to get me and eventually I made it up to her house on the third floor where she greeted me warmly in her pajamas (it was about 5 pm, but my host family does the same thing where as soon as they get home from work they put on their pjs).

Our first lesson was disrupted by a disagreement in a simple grammar exercise where unfortunately I was right and she was mistaken, and then I decided (mentally) that perhaps it would be better to focus on media and leave my grammar studies for home. After the lesson we turned our attention to the television, which was covering demonstrations in Lebanon celebrating the release of four wrongly-jailed suspects in the assassination of Lebanese PM Rafiq Hariri over four years ago.

Weekend Update

Let’s start with last weekend. Thursday evening I went with my host mom, Leila, to a classical music concert in an old Greek church called Church Zeitoon (Olive Church) in the old city. The orchestra performing was visiting from a church in London and played a mixture of classical ‘spiritually-themed’ music and contemporary Christian music, which was overall much more bearable/enjoyable than the previous week’s performance. Some of the songs included audience sing-alongs, for which there was a program on every seat with lyrics in English and Arabic. The crowd was mostly Syrians but there were also a few foreigners scattered, many of whom Leila knew from church.

There was a local Syrian pastor acting as translator for the British pastor, who worked at a local church and was hosting the event, and the British conductor, who was a little crazy and invariably tried to make his speech more welcoming to the foreign/local audience but at the same time made it impossible for the other pastor to translate. I could understand enough of what the translator said to see how much he condensed and simplified the speech of the conductor, and there were times when the conductor would list off foreign cities and composers and the translator would stop mid-sentence and ask how to pronounce something, or try to keep up but then trail off and disregard the rest.

Translation was also a problem when the Greek Patriarch stood up to make a speech and made it in Arabic, and the poor translator was so confused that he began condensing it into Arabic instead of English. Also, when it came time for the audience sing-along, the conductor invited up a man from Leila’s church to lead the Arabic singing while he himself led the English singing, at the same time. Of course the English was drowned out and it sounded terrible. Also I could read enough of the Arabic to know that it did not say anything of the original English lyrics and that they had been completely rewritten into contemporary Christian verse, which was something of a crime for traditional hymns such as Ode to Joy.

The whole event lasted nearly 2 ½ hours, with maybe 17 songs and an intermission, and a lot of prayers and announcements at the end. Afterwards I went with Leila to visit one of her friends that we met at the concert, who lived nearby and invited us over for tea. They lived near the hotel that my parents and I stayed in in the old city, in one of the apartments of an old Damascene house on the upper floor above a courtyard of lemon and orange trees. We stayed for about 20 minutes, until about 11 pm, and it was my first typical house visit for tea, Easter sweets and awkward conversation. Afterwards I walked to my friend’s house in another part of the old city to switch gears and go to a student party in another old Damascene house. When I arrived, the party had already split into the British faction and the American faction. The Americans were greatly outnumbered, there were only about four of us (myself, my friend from class and 2 kids from Princeton, who were exactly what I expected two guys studying Arabic at Princeton to be like). The foreign student social scene is pretty much exactly like it is, well, in America and Britain, except that everyone goes to the same one bar with bad music, lured in by weekly “specials” of free entry and one free drink. However it manages to be a good time regardless.

Wednesday, April 22, 2009

The Last of the Traveling Pics (for now)

My dad posted the rest of his traveling photos; find them here.

Also I'm pretty sure today was the hottest day yet: 89 degrees! It begins...

Oh Right, School.

On Monday, after the national holiday, I returned to the university to begin another month of class. I am definitely grateful to be back in school after a long break, and this class in particular looks promising. It started out with eight students and has now shrunk to six (two opted to advance to level seven); our professor, Huda, is firm and a good teacher with a lot of personality and a good sense of humor, and even our sessions with the listening professor, Abdurabuh (his name means ‘worshipper of his god’), are off to a good start.

Our class is made up of two Korean girls, one British guy, two Americans (myself and a graduate from Yale) and one Swiss woman. The students who left were American and British as well, and I was not sad to see them go since they were both a little bit of know-it-alls, though I still can’t understand how the American kid knows so much (Liz, he’s another Spokaner! so no wonder he is crazy) because this is the first time he has ever studied Arabic in a university/classroom setting, or even with a professor, or even with anyone he can actually speak Arabic with. Instead he studied on his own for three years (on the side, while he got his degrees in computer science, political science and Islamic studies), making it through all three Al-Kitaabs (the standard Arabic textbook in the US), and apparently learned to speak from listening to internet programs—all of which are seemingly impossible.

Class usually begins with a discussion about the news, so yesterday Huda started class by asking us about Ahmedinijad’s speech at the racism conference that singled out Israel and caused attendees to walk out of the room and others to boycott the conference altogether. She noticed that Sammy and myself (the two Americans) stayed quiet for the conversation so she called us out on it and asked if it was because Americans are afraid to talk about politics here. I told her I just don’t like to participate in a discussion, especially in Arabic, if I don’t know what I am talking about, but regardless it started another conversation about the way this country is portrayed in the media as a religiously conservative and closed society and Western perceptions of muhajibeen (women who wear the headscarf/hijab); and although I didn’t suffer from too much culture shock when I arrived due to these misconceived notions, it was nonetheless refreshing to have this kind of conversation with a woman here who dresses conservatively and wears a white hijab and is strong, intelligent, opinionated and well-informed.

She also informed us that we would be responsible for two ! presentations this month, and that since my name was on top of the class list, I would be first to go. Therefore I gave my presentation this morning and used the same subject that I used in my last class (about America’s cultural food crisis) as I never had the chance to finish my presentation last time or open it up to any kind of discussion. This time I had 15 minutes to talk and 30 minutes for discussion and I survived and the class participated and all was well with the world. Then I came home after class and had lunch with my host mother (leftover stuffed grapeleaves from yesterday’s lunch and green beans in tomato sauce) and we were talking about how good the green beans were and how she cooked them with the tomatoes and garlic without boiling them in water in order to retain the flavor and how she used tomatoes that she preserved from last summer because the tomatoes now aren’t any good, and then I turned on CNN afterwards and there was a news story about Japan’s declining economy and how that is pushing more people to eat McDonald’s rather than the traditional healthy (though expensive) Japanese diet and how McDonald’s had record profits in 2008 while the rest of the country/world was falling to pieces. And it all comes together like so.

Who Says You Can’t Talk About Religion and Politics Here?

Saturday I left the house because the cleaning lady was there and returned later in the afternoon to a house cleaned and decorated for Easter. Colored eggs hanging on the wall, bowls of candies, stuffed chicks, ducks and bunnies sitting in various corners of the rooms. I spent some time with my family the only way I know how, sitting and watching TV with them (it really seems to be, unfortunately, the only group activity they partake in, other than eating and church). The past few days, since its been a holiday and my host father didn’t travel to his farm this weekend and I hadn’t started my new class yet, I’ve been spending an inordinate amount of time watching TV with them. Sometimes it is good because my host father will watch the news, either in English or Arabic, or maybe Farah will be watching an American movie, so I can justify my television-time as 1) ‘quality’ time with the family 2) creating opportunities for conversation/discussion and 3) listening practice! (this is clearly a good excuse for just about anything I wouldn’t otherwise want to do) or in the case of movies in English, translation practice as I switch between listening and reading the subtitles (mostly paying attention to how they translate American slang into formal fus’ha).

If my host mom is watching, however, or if the family is watching together, the channel is usually on one of the 10 or so Christian channels (there must be some kind of satellite TV programming where you buy the package based on your religion, clearly Muslims would have different channel options), either showing a debate, lecture, preach-fest with a televangelist, musical event, religious film or most unfortunate of them all/my host mother’s favorite, kids’ programming (although my hostfamily belongs to a Protestant church, their religious activities suggest a likening to evangelism).

This particular session started out promising. My hostfather was watching a political debate on an Iraqi news channel between four men (two Arabs and 2 Americans) about the Palestinian-Israeli conflict. It was most interesting because it may have been the first time that I saw a Westerner/American participate in a debate in the media with Arabs and actually speak to them in fus’ha (the other American spoke English and had it translated). It was encouraging for me to watch as a student, because it reminded me that there may be some purpose to my studies after all; though I may not ever be in this exact context, it exemplified the benefit of being able to have a discussion between Western and Arab perspectives on the same level/in the same language. Likely the other participants knew English well enough, but it was an Arab TV channel with a debate in an Arab context with an American guest—plus, one can appreciate the symbolic gesture/rarity of having an American in this field/in this position of knowledge/power/influence know fus’ha well enough to speak it.

But the channel was soon changed to a religious debate between a priest and a Muslim on the vowelling in the Qu’ran [at the time of the revelation of the Qu’ran, the written Arabic langauge didn’t include diacritics such as short vowels, so there is debate (primarily among Christians, that is) over whether different versions of the Qu’ran exist and if Muslims even really know what their Holy Book says]. Although I’m all for a good religious or political debate, and even though I didn’t fully understand what they were saying, I didn’t like the look of this priest and I didn’t need to hear him to not trust the words that were coming out of his mouth that I couldn’t understand. Plus I don’t trust any of these channels because I figure that anything written by Christians for Christian audiences in order to boost their self-esteem about how much more correct their religion is compared to the Other Religion, is more than a little suspect. It’s like when they bring Muslims on the show who have converted to Christianity in order to explain the differences between the religions and why his new religion/Your Religion is the better choice.

Thus I have realized that not everything can be endured for the sake of language practice (and I now have to leave the room everytime the channel is changed to one of the first 10). There does, in fact, have to be SOME substance in what is being communicated in order to even have the desire to figure out the meaning.

Yet here is an example of the same idea from the other end of the spectrum: I went out a few nights ago to meet Frank and a friend of his to go to a poetry reading. Frank has only studied Arabic for a few months and his friend doesn’t even really study Arabic (I forget why he is here) so we all acknowledged the fact that we probably wouldn’t understand anything but it was worth the visit. But first, we hung out for a bit with Frank’s roommates and their friends and sweets that two Syrian girls had brought from Homs. The group spoke English/French/Arabic/German and it was the first time that the only common language was Arabic (finally!) so I had a good conversation in fus’ha with a friend who is French and Muslim and here to study the language in relation to his religion.

After some time, we left for the reading, which was held in a bar located in the basement of a five-star hotel and packed with locals, cigarette smoke and bottles of beer. Admittedly, it was a little pretentious for any foreigner to go to such an event and pretend to appreciate anything that was being said, but at the very least, it was a great cultural experience—for one, because the poets were definitely local but shared origins from Libya to Iraq to Palestine, and for another because poetry is an important part of the Arab literary tradition and though I’ve had to (attempt to) read some in class this was the first time I ever heard it performed. And though the scene itself was not unfamiliar: the darkened room, jazz posters on the wall and people crammed wherever they could fit: the people showed their appreciation not with snaps or polite clapping but with shouts and raucous applause and calling out or jumping to the podium themselves.

--

Sunday was the most important day of the year, again. I slept in again, even did a little (/a lot of) studying in order to prepare for my return to the university the following day. We had lunch again with the family in the garden—this time we had frikie (at first I thought it was called Afrikiye aka African food), a green wheat served with cashews, tender lamb chunks on the bone and a yogurt and cucumber sauce.

During the meal, the conversation was appropriately themed for the holiday and the others tried to bring me into the discussion by asking if I knew that Muslims didn’t believe in the resurrection of Jesus (they believe in him as a prophet and therefore have respect for the religion of Christianity but they don’t agree that he is the son of God and divine in nature) and then a little later if I knew that the Muslims don’t believe in Jesus in the way that he is written about in the Bible, only through the words of the Qu’ran. Yes, that is because they are…Muslims. And they can’t believe in the divinity of Jesus because they believe it is not possible for God to live on earth, and if they believed in Jesus according to the Bible, and took the Bible as God’s Word, well, then they would be Christians. You realize that you are two different religions, right?

Then post-lunch: Ihab started by asking me if I believe in Jesus Christ. He already knew that I didn’t believe in the religiousity of the story, so he clarified it by asking if I believed in his existence from a historical perspective. He prefaced the conversation by saying he hoped he wasn’t offending me, but that there is not much opportunity for this kind of religious debate and he was curious to know what I thought about some of religion’s big questions: life and death, creation, human nature, divine nature, the meaning of life. I did most of the talking, but ultimately I tried to explain that usually I find that in talking with people of different beliefs that we share similar hopes/dreams/fears about life and what it all means, where it all comes from—we just happen to use different words or metaphors to represent our ideas. He responded that this isn’t true because I don’t have God in my heart; I said well you can call it God and I can call it something else, but how do you know what is in my heart? and again that we all share the same questions about life but we have different ways of getting to the answer, but it doesn’t mean any one way is better than the other—and then he told me, no that’s not true, I have the right and the best way. Henceforth the conversation went downhill from there, finally ending with a crash and burn when he told me “I believe that if only you thought about it more, you would see that I am right.”

Wafa in her broken English intervened with, “I believe in the end, we get what we plant and we love you anyway.”